Only one shipping option
About 1 in 6 stores we audit show shoppers only one shipping option at checkout, with no economy or express choice and no agency for the shopper.
PDQ store audits
Shipping Personalization
Build an ecommerce shipping strategy shoppers can choose from
Shipping today is one-size-fits-all: the same rates, names, and promises for a first-timer in a far zone and a VIP a mile from the warehouse. A good ecommerce shipping strategy personalizes that choice by segment, zone, and cart, then tests the mix that converts without giving away margin.
Delivered in 3 business days.
What does a weak shipping strategy cost?
Based on PDQ audits of 600+ Shopify stores, each benchmarked against its own industry.
Shoppers cannot self-select
One method forces every shopper into the same speed and price. The value buyer cannot trade time for savings, and the urgent buyer cannot pay for speed.
The store learns nothing
One option is not a shipping strategy. With nothing to compare, there is no way to test the rate, label, anchor, or delivery promise that converts each segment.
What does a real ecommerce shipping strategy look like?
It gives shoppers a useful choice, then treats every rate, name, and anchor as something to test. These are the tactics PDQ runs inside checkout.
01
Give shoppers a real choice
A single shipping method gives the shopper no agency and gives you no room to test. PDQ builds a proper ladder: economy, standard, and express, so shoppers self-select and every segment gets a rate that fits. This is the fix for the most common shipping mistake we find in audits.
02
Anchor the price with a premium option
Introduce a higher-priced express method and standard reads as the reasonable choice. Labeling the anchor “Limited Time Offer” or “Special Price” raises the perceived value of the whole shipping decision and pushes conversion at the method the shopper was already likely to pick.
03
Add Premium Standard as a small upgrade
A slightly better delivery promise for a small dollar increase, such as “Premium Standard, get it faster, $1.99,” pushes up average shipping revenue and conversion at once.
04
Round the rate, and tag the best value
Two framings test well. Rounding an $11.19 rate to a clean $11.99 makes pricing feel simpler and lifts revenue per checkout. Adding a “Best Value” tag steers shoppers toward the option you want them to take.
05
Capture the real cost with live rates
Pinging carriers in real time means charging the accurate rate on every order, not a stale flat rate that either eats margin or scares off the shopper. Combined with percentage-of-cart rate rules, shipping stops being a cost center you guess at.
Powered by
What do PDQ's winning A/B tests deliver?
A measured conversion result, not a shipping-revenue claim.
+19% CVR
PDQ's winning A/B tests deliver this average improvement, measured across 36 experiments
Ecommerce shipping strategy questions
What is a good ecommerce shipping strategy?
A good ecommerce shipping strategy gives shoppers a clear choice between economy, standard, and express delivery, then prices and frames those methods to support conversion and margin. The right mix is tested by shopper segment rather than copied from a generic industry rule.
How should I price shipping at checkout?
Price shipping by testing what each shopper segment will accept while measuring revenue per checkout, not conversion alone. Test the rate itself, clean rounding, premium anchors, percentage-of-cart rules, and live carrier pricing instead of relying on one stale flat rate.
Is free shipping or flat-rate shipping better?
Neither is universally better. The right choice depends on margin, cart distribution, delivery cost, and how shoppers respond; this page covers the structure and pricing of paid methods, while the dedicated Free Shipping Threshold solution owns the question of where to set the threshold.
How many shipping options should I offer at checkout?
Most stores should start with a useful three-step ladder: economy, standard, and express. That gives shoppers enough agency to self-select without turning checkout into a rate table, and gives the merchant real options to test.
Should ecommerce stores use live carrier rates?
Live carrier rates help stores charge the real delivery cost on each order instead of guessing with a stale flat rate. They work best when combined with clear method names, delivery promises, and rules that account for cart value and shopper segment.
Related checkout problems
Free Shipping Threshold
Find the exact threshold that maximizes revenue per checkout
Checkout Abandonment
Stop losing 7 in 10 shoppers at the finish line
Checkout Issues Report
Not sure where you're leaking? Start with the 12 most common checkout issues, from 600+ store audits.
